Income Capitalization Analysis
The Income Capitalization includes income and expense projections tools, net operating income calculations, capitalization rate tools and of course the value indication. Numerous types of income and expense projections can be made and this data can be further broken out by square foot, unit or percentage measures. The major components and indicators are:
The Effective Gross Income Multiplier (EGIM) and Net Income Multiplier (NIM) analyses are located at the bottom part of this worksheet.
Income Projection
There are two options for developing the income projection:
This works similar to income projection section: enter data from left to right.
The Net Operating Income (NOI) is calculated automatically (EGI-Expenses). The capitalization rate (cap rate tools are described below) is entered by the analyst, as is the final and the final rounded value. Final cap rates and and values would be inappropriate to automate and are always hand entered to ensure appraiser judgment in the valuation process.
Capitalization Rates
The capitalization rate is the ratio of net operating income to sale price, or NOI / Sale Price.
Band of Investment and Debt Coverage Ratio Methods
These methods calculate from the same set of inputs.
Band of Investment Method
This technique utilizes lender and real estate investor investment criteria to develop, or synthesize a capitalization rate. There are four key inputs necessary for this method:
The equity cap rate is the annual return to the investor, expressed as a percent of the original amount invested. The annual return to the investor is also known as the equity dividend rate; it is the profit remaining after debt service and all other expenses.
Note that the equity cap rate is not the same (usually, that is) as the equity yield rate. The equity yield rate reflects the total return to the investor over the life of the investment. Factors such as appreciation and mortgage pay down affect and usually increase this return to a point higher than the equity dividend rate. In markets where substantial appreciation is expected, investors will often accept a low or even negative equity dividend rate, anticipating a compensating payoff when the property is eventually sold. In markets where little appreciation is expected, much more weight is given to the annual equity dividend.
Formula:
Debt Coverage Ratio Method
This technique develops a capitalization rate based on typical mortgage terms. There are four variables necessary for this method:
Formula:
Comparable Sale Cap Rates
This table is at the bottom of the Dir Cap worksheet. Comparable sale cap rate tables can be automatically populated from comps selected in the Sales Grid sheet, or hand entered (this requires unprotected the sheet and over-writing the formulas).
If the cap rates comps are different than those used in the Sales Grid sheet, simply create a second Sales Grid sheet, populate that sheet with cap rate comps, then point to the sheet as the database source for the cap rate table as shown below.
EGIM Analysis
Narrative1 notes that EGIM Analysis is often considered a sales analysis method, however, in our view it is more closely aligned with income characteristics and therefor we have the EGIM Analysis part of the income section.
The Effective Gross Income Multiplier (EGIM) is the ratio of sale price to income:
This method is popular for multifamily properties. Analysts should be mindful that EGIMs are highly sensitive to expense ratios. Typically, the higher the expense ratio, the lower the EGIM and vice versa.
Similar to the cap rate tables described above, the EGIM table can be
automatically populated from comps selected in the Sales Grid sheet, or
hand entered (this requires unprotected the sheet and over-writing the
formulas). As noted above, iIf the EGIM comps are different than those
used in the Sales Grid sheet, simply create a second Sales Grid sheet, populate that sheet with EGIM comps, then point to the sheet as the database source for the EGIM table as shown below.
Net Income Multiplier Analysis (NIM)
This analysis is located directly under the EGIM analysis and is nearly identical in terms of how the tables function. However, unlike the EGIM analysis, the NIM is not sensitive to the Expense Ratio.
The Income Capitalization includes income and expense projections tools, net operating income calculations, capitalization rate tools and of course the value indication. Numerous types of income and expense projections can be made and this data can be further broken out by square foot, unit or percentage measures. The major components and indicators are:
- Potential Gross Income
- Vacancy & Collection Loss
- Effective Gross Income
-
Expenses, Reimbursements & Expense Ratio
- Net Operating Income
-
Cap Rate Tools:
- Band of Investment
- Debt Coverage Ratio
- Comparable Sales Cap Rate Table
-
Value Indication
- Income
- Expenses
- NOI, Cap Rate & Value
- Band of Investment
- Debt Coverage Ratio
- Comparable Sales Cap Rate Table
The Effective Gross Income Multiplier (EGIM) and Net Income Multiplier (NIM) analyses are located at the bottom part of this worksheet.
Income Projection
There are two options for developing the income projection:
- Populate Potential Gross Income from Rent Roll sheet. If the Rent Roll was completed, this data automatically populates the Income section.
- Clear Rent Roll data, if any, and enter cash flows directly to the Income section, described below:
Income projections are developed from left to right, on a tenant by tenant basis, or by unit types, such as apartments.
-
Identify the unit by tenant name, space or unit type (e.g., "2 Bedroom")
-
Enter the method of projection. This must match exactly one of the methods from the list at right.
- Enter the number of units or square foot area, depending on the method of income projection. Note that "$/Year" projections are not sensitive to this input - it can be any entry or left blank. It is a good practice to enter square footage or some kind of descriptor to aid the reader.
-
Vacancy and collection loss is entered as a percentage. Alternatively,
the percentage cell can be cleared and a dollar amount entered directly
under the PGI amount (requires unprotecting the sheet).
- Other Income is for miscellaneous income that is not subject to vacancy and collection loss.
This works similar to income projection section: enter data from left to right.
- Start with the expense item label
- Enter the amount as a lump sum, per square foot, or per unit dollar amount, or as a percent of Effective Gross Income, formatting the entry accordingly.
- Enter the method of projection.
Expense Reimbursements
This table is located immediately to the right of the expense section and automatically populates. A given expense reimbursement will be added to the reimbursement table when 'Yes" is listed in the Reimbursed column (Yes/No can be toggled via double-click). The expense amount reimbursed is automatically adjusted for vacancy/collection loss. For example, if taxes are $12,000 and vacancy and collection loss is 10%, the amount of reimbursed taxes is $10,800 ($12,000 x .9).
The total reimbursement is added to the NOI in the Capitalization table.
NOI & Capitalization to ValueThis table is located immediately to the right of the expense section and automatically populates. A given expense reimbursement will be added to the reimbursement table when 'Yes" is listed in the Reimbursed column (Yes/No can be toggled via double-click). The expense amount reimbursed is automatically adjusted for vacancy/collection loss. For example, if taxes are $12,000 and vacancy and collection loss is 10%, the amount of reimbursed taxes is $10,800 ($12,000 x .9).
The total reimbursement is added to the NOI in the Capitalization table.
The Net Operating Income (NOI) is calculated automatically (EGI-Expenses). The capitalization rate (cap rate tools are described below) is entered by the analyst, as is the final and the final rounded value. Final cap rates and and values would be inappropriate to automate and are always hand entered to ensure appraiser judgment in the valuation process.
Capitalization Rates
The capitalization rate is the ratio of net operating income to sale price, or NOI / Sale Price.
Band of Investment and Debt Coverage Ratio Methods
These methods calculate from the same set of inputs.
Band of Investment Method
This technique utilizes lender and real estate investor investment criteria to develop, or synthesize a capitalization rate. There are four key inputs necessary for this method:
- The loan-to-value ratio (M)
- The mortgage interest rate (i)
- The loan term (n)
- The equity cap rate or equity dividend rate (RE)
Payments x 12 / Original Loan Amount = Mortgage Constant (RM)
The equity cap rate is the annual return to the investor, expressed as a percent of the original amount invested. The annual return to the investor is also known as the equity dividend rate; it is the profit remaining after debt service and all other expenses.
After Debt Service Profit / Equity Investment = Equity Cap Rate (RE)
Note that the equity cap rate is not the same (usually, that is) as the equity yield rate. The equity yield rate reflects the total return to the investor over the life of the investment. Factors such as appreciation and mortgage pay down affect and usually increase this return to a point higher than the equity dividend rate. In markets where substantial appreciation is expected, investors will often accept a low or even negative equity dividend rate, anticipating a compensating payoff when the property is eventually sold. In markets where little appreciation is expected, much more weight is given to the annual equity dividend.
Formula:
RM x M = rate
RE x (1-M) = rate
= Cap Rate (Ro)
RE x (1-M) = rate
= Cap Rate (Ro)
Debt Coverage Ratio Method
This technique develops a capitalization rate based on typical mortgage terms. There are four variables necessary for this method:
- The loan-to-value ratio (M)
- The mortgage interest rate (i)
- The loan term (n)
- The debt coverage ratio (DCR)
Formula:
Debt Coverage Ratio x Loan to Value Ratio x Mortgage Constant = Ro
or: DCR x M x RM = Ro
or: DCR x M x RM = Ro
Comparable Sale Cap Rates
This table is at the bottom of the Dir Cap worksheet. Comparable sale cap rate tables can be automatically populated from comps selected in the Sales Grid sheet, or hand entered (this requires unprotected the sheet and over-writing the formulas).
If the cap rates comps are different than those used in the Sales Grid sheet, simply create a second Sales Grid sheet, populate that sheet with cap rate comps, then point to the sheet as the database source for the cap rate table as shown below.
EGIM Analysis
Narrative1 notes that EGIM Analysis is often considered a sales analysis method, however, in our view it is more closely aligned with income characteristics and therefor we have the EGIM Analysis part of the income section.
The Effective Gross Income Multiplier (EGIM) is the ratio of sale price to income:
Sale Price / Effective Gross Income = EGIM
$1,000,000/$120,000 = 8.333
$1,000,000/$120,000 = 8.333
This method is popular for multifamily properties. Analysts should be mindful that EGIMs are highly sensitive to expense ratios. Typically, the higher the expense ratio, the lower the EGIM and vice versa.
Net Income Multiplier Analysis (NIM)
This analysis is located directly under the EGIM analysis and is nearly identical in terms of how the tables function. However, unlike the EGIM analysis, the NIM is not sensitive to the Expense Ratio.
The Net Income Multiplier (NIM) is the ratio of sale price to net income:
Sale Price / Net Oporating Income = NIM
$1,000,000/$84,000 = 11.9
$1,000,000/$84,000 = 11.9
Tip: Help pages can be printed (link at bottom), but hey, we're all going green, so please think twice before printing.
Screen shots shown here may be slightly different than your version of Excel N1Appraisal.xls
Screen shots shown here may be slightly different than your version of Excel N1Appraisal.xls